Comparison & Experience With Both of 1&1 Hosting vs. HostGator (Part I)
1&1 hosting is one of the oldest and biggest hosting brands in the world, while HostGator is one of the fastest growing web hosting companies in recent years. I wanted to compare 1&1 Hosting vs. HostGator specifically after receiving several reader questions about the 1&1 brand (mainly b/c 1&1, like GoDaddy does a ton of advertising).
With site test (and most of my others) runs on HostGator hosting (see HostGator’s plans here), and I’ve had the opportunity to use 1&1 hosting (see 1&1’s plans here) with several client sites, in addition to a recent side project that uses 1&1 hosting. After using each for quite a while, here’s my experience with how 1&1 and Hostgator compare on pricing, features, performance, usability, and customer service.
Pricing
Comparing web hosts on pricing is always a bit difficult since they try to make sure the comparison is never apples to apples, when really they are all selling the same thing.
For price comparisons, I try to keep the 3 D’s straight – domains, databases, and disk space. When it comes to shared Linux hosting (which, unless you know otherwise is probably going to be the best fit for you). Those are the 3 features that you are really paying for – everything is else is nice, but can’t really be compared directly.
Domains is the number of domains you can point to your hosting account. Depending on the exact account – you could have unlimited “websites” that live all on 1 domain. You could have blog.domain.com along with shop.domain.com and support.domain.com – each would be distinct site but all on the single domain.com. HostGator’s cheapest account (Hatchling) allows 1, as does 1&1’s two cheapest (Starter & Basic). Both their mid-tier options are unlimited.